The meaning of the precautionary principle the uncertainty surrounding potential threats to the environment has frequently been used as a reason to avoid taking action to protect the environment. Kerry whiteside looks at the application of the principle and the controversies it has stirred and compares european and american attitudes. The evolution and international acceptance of the precautionary principle jon m. The precautionary principle must be a general principle of eu law requires careful analysis and confirmation by the court of justice of the eu prior to brexit day represents a general principle of food law fidenato c11116, but not necessarily eu law based in part on eu commitment to achieving highlevel. It is, by the treaty on european union 1992, the basis for european environmental law, and plays an increasing role in. This principle is the basis for european environmental law. The precautionary principle unesdoc unesco mafiadoc. While some scholars emphasize on terrorism as a risk, others alert on the limitations of thinking. Precautionary principle law and legal definition uslegal. Principle definition is a comprehensive and fundamental law, doctrine, or assumption. Almost all definitions of the precautionary principle identify scientific uncertainties as the trigger or criterion for its invocation. Ebm is conservative in that its use will not allow the use of new. For the evaluation of most treatments, particularly drugs, it is not known in advance whether the treatment will give positive benefits in the form of an improved main outcome compared with a relevant comparator. Precaution means tak ing action to protect human health and the environ.
Wingspread statement on the precautionary principle. Beware the precautionary principle social research. Jun 18, 2019 the precautionary principle counters such general presumptions. When there is uncertainty regarding the impacts of an activity, the precautionary principle advocates action to anticipate and avert environmental harm. Food and drug safety ed soule the mcdonough school of business at georgetown university, washington, dc, usa abstract this article probes the advisability of regulating u. A sociocultural and legal approach summary what is the precautionary principle.
The precautionary principle states that if there is risk of severe damage to humans andor the environment, absence of incontrovertible, conclusive, or definite scientific proof is not a reason for inaction. The precautionary principle states that serious environmental threats and health. The precautionary principle should not be used to try to avoid all risks. Born of environmental considerations, the precautionary principle has since matured into an ethical principle with a far broader scope and the potential value of the precautionary principle as a policy guide should be envisaged. The principle status as follows in order to protect the environment, the precautionary approach shall be widely applied by states according to their capabilities. The burden of evidence and proof is taken away from those who make unjustified and often whimsical claims and placed on the scientific community which, because it proceeds logically and rationally, is often. The principle provides guidance on a process for avoiding serious. Incomplete information, inconclusive evidence and public controversy can make it difficult to achieve consensus over the appropriate response. Chem a constituent of a substance that gives the substance its characteristics and behaviour principle the basic initial assumption of any theory, teaching, science, world view, or political organization. The principle is used by policy makers to justify discretionary decisions in situations where there is the possibility of harm from making a certain decision e.
Defending the precautionary principle against three criticisms 367 example, marine and fisheries protection, the conservation of our natural environment, climate change and global warming regulation and debate, the protection of the ozone layer, the nuclear power risk, the risks of radio frequency electro. If used intelligently, imaginatively and daringly, the precautionary principle will support efforts to. When an activity raises threats of harm to human health or the environment, precautionary measures should be taken even if some causeandeffect relationships are not fully established scientifically. It is a bettersafethansorry approach, in contrast with the traditional reactive waitandsee approach to environmental protection. The precautionary principle synonyms, the precautionary principle pronunciation, the precautionary principle translation, english dictionary definition of the precautionary principle. The precautionary principle highlights this tight, challenging linkage between science and policy. The meaning of uncertainty is also more complex than might be apparent. This future brief explores the role of the precautionary principle in eu law and policy, and examines key points of discussion drawn from the evidence. There are multiple interpretations of the precautionary principle ranging from stronger interpretations, which essentially state that persuasive evidence of harm does not have to exist before measures are taken to protect individuals and society from the harm, to weaker interpretations which argue that actions taken to protect against a harm could be taken, but are not required, and the costs. It has however become of increased importance in eu law. The precautionary principle is also a key component of the environment protection and biodiversity conservation act 1999 epbc act, a significant piece of legislation with broad applicability to environmental, natural resource management, and conservation activities.
In particular, we shall examine the optimality of precautionary policies for. The invocation of the precautionary principle consists of two crucial elements. The precautionary principle invokes preventative action. It is, by the treaty on european union 1992, the basis for european environmental law, and plays an increasing role in developing. The current dialogue between the eu and the united states on the use and application of precaution is partly affected by confusion about the meaning of terms used in the debate.
Defining precautionary principle is difficult since. The precautionary principle or precautionary approach states that if an action or policy has a suspected risk of causing harm to the public or to the environment, in the absence of scientific consensus that the action or policy is harmful, the burden of proof that it is not harmful falls on those taking the action. Understanding the precautionary principle the ocean foundation. The chapter concludes by assessing the principle from a more normative dimension. Precautionary politics provides a comprehensive analysis of the precautionary principleits origins and development, its meaning and rationale, its theoretical context, and its policy implications. In classifying endangered species, the precautionary principle means that if there is.
Understanding and applying the precautionary principle to deep sea minerals mining in the pacific islands region. Nanotechnologies and the precautionary principle jennifer sass, ph. What i will argue is that the similarities are deep, and that the problem of the risks of change, the problem of knowledge. The principle provides guidance on a process for avoiding serious or irreversible harm under conditions of uncertainty. The conservative disposition and the precautionary principle. The precautionary principle in environmental science 145. The pp may be applied to many aspects of healthcare evaluation. The precautionary principle is not just an issue for the european union eu. However, there is no universally accepted definition of the principle. When human activities may lead to morally unacceptable harm that is.
The precautionary principle in its simplest form states. The precautionary principle precautionary principle. The precautionary principle or precautionary approach is a broad epistemological. The precautionary principle counters such general presumptions. Treich 21 explores the economic meaning of the precautionary principle from different approaches.
While the precautionary principle is found in some legal systems, such as germany, it is nonetheless relatively novel as a precept of administrative law. Precautionary principle article about precautionary. In particular, we shall examine the optimality of precautionary policies for the climatechange problem. Principle is normally used as a noun meaning a fundamental basis of a system of thought or belief, as in this is one of the basic principles of democracy. Finally, the publication gives an overview of certain aspects of governance and the precautionary principle, namely risk governance, the sciencepolicy interface and the links between precaution and innovation. A rule in environment management which states that if serious damage can be caused to the environment and or to the health of a human being, immediate the law dictionary featuring blacks law dictionary free online legal dictionary 2nd ed. May 12, 2000 f ew policies for risk management have created as much controversy as the precautionary principle.
Woodward and bishop 22 confirm arrow and hurwicz 1 results applied to the nordhaus 14. Using the precautionary principle for the management of global commons in this section, wewill examine the implications of the pp for the management of global pollution problems. Introducing the precautionary approach, principle 15 of the 1992 rio declaration states that where there are threats of serious or irreversible damage, lack of full scientific certainty shall not be used as a reason for postponing costeffective measures to prevent environmental degradation. On different types of uncertainties in the context of the. The precautionary principle has been gaining prominence and profile and has become a guiding principle in modern thinking in environment and health a most welcome development for who and everyone engaged in public health. There is considerable controversy over the meaning of the precautionary principle and its application.
A main problem is the extreme number of different definitions and interpretations. Precaution definition of precaution by merriamwebster. Precautionary principle legal definition of precautionary. The precautionary principle is a strategy to cope with possible risks where scientific understanding is yet incomplete, such as the risks of nano technology, genetically modified organisms and systemic insecticides.
Full text the full text of this article is available as a pdf 66k. The precautionary principle and the regulation of u. Precautionary principle states that when an activity causes some threat or harm to the public or the environment, general precautionary measures should be taken. The precautionary principle recognizes that delaying action until there is compelling evidence of harm will often mean that it is then too costly or impossible to. This future brief explores the role of the precautionary principle in eu law and policy, and examines key. Scientific uncertainty means that decision makers cannot appeal to adequate. Environment management rule that if a threat of serious or irreversible damage to the environment or human health exists, a lack of full scientific knowledge about the situation should not be allowed to delay containment or remedial steps if the balance of potential costs and benefits justifies enacting them. An element common to the various formulations of the precautionary principle is the recognition that lack of certainty regarding the threat.
Principle definition of principle by merriamwebster. The design and application of modern environmental law have been shaped by a set of principles and concepts outlined in publications such as our common future 1987, published by the world commission on environment and development, and the earth summits rio declaration 1992. Furthermore, whether there is a difference in meaning between precautionary defending the precautionary principle against three criticisms 369 principle and precautionary approach is not commonly agreed upon see e. This chapter centers on the discussion around terrorism.
From there, partly on the basis of the anticatastrophe principle mentioned by sunstein, we discuss the meaning of the precautionary principle for the fight against terrorism under criminal law. Precautionary principle an overview sciencedirect topics. The precautionary principle, originating in the field of environmental protection but now widely applied, is a major point for discussion in the regulation of risk. Precautionary principles are the foundations for policy when it has to deal with weakly understood causes of potential catastrophic or irreversible events, and where protective decisions require certain and costly policy interventions that may not.
Precautionary principle environmental justice organisations. The principle is to be applied in cases of potential adverse impacts on the environment or human health with serious consequences thus implying that. Precautionary principle definition of precautionary. Precautionary principle definition and meaning collins.
In the european union, it was enshrined in article r 2i of the treaty of maastricht 1992, and reference is made to it. Principal, on the other hand, is normally an adjective meaning main or most important, as in one of the countrys principal cities. The precautionary principle european commission europa eu. Various interpretations of the precautionary principle. The most universal description of the precautionary principle is that it seeks to impose early preventive measures to ward off even those risks for which we. Van dyke during the past two decades, the precautionary principle has evolved from being a soft law aspirational goal to its present status as an authoritative norm recognized by governments and international organizations as.
Strong versions of the precautionary principle obligate decision makers to take precautionary action, and therefore perhaps offers the greatest protection, however cannot differentiate. When a scientific investigation proves that there is a possible risk in doing some activity, then this principle should be applied. When an activity raises threats of harm to human health or the environment, precautionary measures should be taken even if some causeand. It states that in order to protect the environment every state should apply the principle to the best of their abilities. The precautionary principle has been widely incorporated, in various forms, in international environmental agreements and declarations and further developed in a number of national laws. Second extrinsic choice is the determination of the general level of protection or of the. The precautionary principle is, however, a very useful one for consumer activists precisely because it prevents scientific debate. Environmental law principles of environmental law britannica. There are two definitions of precautionary principle which are widely acceptedthe first definition is given in the rio declaration of 1992. The precautionary principle, evidencebased medicine, and. The precautionary principle whoeurope world health.
The 32 authors of the statement are listed beneath the statement. The precautionary principle or precautionary approach states that if an action or policy has a suspected risk of causing harm to the public or to the environment, in the absence of scientific consensus that the action or policy is harmful, the burden of proof that it is not harmful falls on those taking the action this principle allows policy makers to make discretionary decisions in. What is the economic meaning of the precautionary principle. In order to protect the environment, the precautionary approach. F ew policies for risk management have created as much controversy as the precautionary principle. The precautionary principle states that when an activity raises the threat of harm to human health or the environment, precautionary measures should be taken even if some cause and effect relationships are not yet fully established scientifically, says author guy dauncey. It considers the political status of the principle and the way in which it informs decisionmaking. The precautionary principle unesco digital library.
This chapter begins by examining the development of the precautionary principle into a general principle of eu law. Precautionary principles are the foundations for policy when it has to deal with weakly understood causes of potential catastrophic or irreversible events, and where protective decisions require certain and costly policy interventions that may not solve the problem that they are designed to correct. The precautionary principle is one of the important principles under the concept of sustainable development. The choice is sociopolitical and ethical in nature, and it should be based upon commonly accepted and relevant reasons. Thus, the precautionary principle favours monitoring, preventing andor mitigating uncertain potential threats. The precautionary principle specifies a rationale and legal basis for governmental action in the context of inconclusive scientific evidence.
Few policies for risk management have created more controversy than the precautionary principle. It first emerged during the 1970s and has since been enshrined in a number of international treaties on the environment, in the treaty on the functioning of the european union and the national. However, it is not always possible to have clear evidence of a threat to the environment. The precautionary principle, proposed as a new guideline in environmental decision making, has four central components. Precautionary meaning in the cambridge english dictionary. The similarities between oakeshotts account of the conservative disposition and the precautionary principle are obvious but perhaps superficial. Emerging in european environmental policies in the late 1970s 11, the principle has become enshrined in numerous international treaties and declarations.
1577 1110 1269 195 1070 1438 1263 1105 1265 1659 591 1396 404 1289 2 1241 1455 1169 89 1058 657 1420 261 1340 844 1446 454 945 757 137 374 223 420 604 1242